Most managers can tell you what they wanted an employee to do differently. Ask what they themselves would change about the conversation, and the answer can take a little longer. That second question is the one Tanya Stone, founder of Stone Catalyst, wants leaders to spend time with.
When Tanya joined me on Shaping Success, she described what she does after giving someone difficult feedback, even when she’s had to let someone go. She thinks about what she could do to help that person, or the next person in the role, do better. The decision may stand. There’s still something for the manager to learn.
When your life looks settled from the outside
Tanya married at 19. By her thirties, she remembers thinking she already knew what the rest of her life would look like. Other people’s ideas about who she was had become a big part of how she saw herself. At 40, newly divorced, she moved into her first apartment and got a car on her own. Those might sound like milestones from someone’s twenties. For Tanya, they were firsts at 40.
What struck me was how ordinary she made reflection sound. When I taught juniors and seniors, I asked students to look back at their projects. They hated that part. I get it: once you’ve turned something in, the last thing you want is another assignment about it. But the grade couldn’t tell them which choice they’d make differently next time. They were the ones who knew where they’d gotten stuck.
A five-minute debrief you can actually use
Here’s one way to try Tanya’s idea. Think about the last time someone missed a deadline. Before deciding they need to communicate better, see whether you can answer three questions:
1. What did I actually say? “I need the figures by noon Thursday” gives someone a deadline. “Get them to me soon” leaves them to guess.
2. What did I learn from their side? Maybe they were waiting on a number only you could approve. Maybe they knew they were behind and didn’t tell you. Those are different problems.
3. What will each of us do next time? They might agree to flag a missing number the day before the deadline. You might agree to tell them who can approve it when you’re away.
That example is mine. The reason I like Tanya’s approach is that both people leave with something specific to do. And you can use it when things go well, too. If the next report arrives on time, ask what helped. You might discover that a two-minute check-in on Wednesday did more good than a long conversation on Friday.
When does talking it over become gossip?
Sometimes the person you need to talk to first is a colleague. Tanya makes room for that. The distinction she draws is what you want from the conversation. Are you willing to hear a way to improve the situation, or do you just want one more person to know how badly it went? Before you retell the story, try naming what you need: “Help me figure out how to bring this up tomorrow.” That gives your colleague a job other than taking sides.
Watch the full conversation with Tanya Stone for the story behind her career change and how she brings kindness and accountability into the same conversation at work:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bHNPmD6BWts
For more Shaping Success Network interviews, subscribe on YouTube:
https://www.youtube.com/@wes.tankersley
Prefer audio? Listen to Shaping Success on Buzzsprout:
https://shapingsuccesspodcast.buzzsprout.com/
Follow the network on Instagram:
@wes.tankersley — https://www.instagram.com/wes.tankersley/
@shapingsuccesspodcast — https://www.instagram.com/shapingsuccesspodcast/
@jhaepfenning — https://www.instagram.com/jhaepfenning/
@onedrinkwednesday — https://www.instagram.com/onedrinkwednesday/
